The end chapter 27

I didn't think that Abline would have a daughter. I wonder who is Ablines husband?

Alyssa
ELC
Malaysia

Chapter 26

It was upsetting when the little girl choose the doll next to Edward in sted of him


Alyssa
Mlayasia
ELC

Chapter 26

I like how the old doll makes Edward have more hope that he can love again. I also like the little girl who gets the old baby doll. Do you like the doll?

Lydia 5th grade (ELC Malaysia)

Chapter 24-25

I don't like the doll that was mean to Edward she's mean and bossy

Alyssa
Malaysia
ELC

Chapter 24-25 (Lydia)

I dislike the dolls for the are being so mean.

Lydia 5th grade (ELC Malaysia)

Chapter 23

Bryce had to give up jangles/Edward but it was for a good cause I guess he wanted Sarah Ruth to be happy.

Alyssa
Malaysia
ELC

Chapter 23 (Lydia)

I feel sad for Bryce for he had to give up Edward. I think the old man is nice but not to Bryce. Do you like the old man?

Lydia 5th grade (ELC Malaysia)

I would not to change the ending.I personally love the ending.The only thing I don't is how Sarah Ruth died.I also would make Pellegrina a nicer person.Other than that I think the book is extraordinary!The author used epic word choice.

How many stars would you rate the book and why?

If you were to change ending,what would you make it and why?

On a scale one to ten how do rate Edward Tulane the book?  I would definitely rate it a nine.

As you read the book, did you even realize that the time went by so fast?

what would you think would happen at the end of the book? Why?

Did you guys think it was going to end like this? Why?

Did you guys expect the book to end like this?

What are your thoughts/feelings about how the book ended? If you could change the ending of the book, how would you change it?

Chapter 19-20

I thin it is sad that Edward had to experience another loss. I also believe that the old lady was not Pellegrina but it was Edward's imagination. I predict that Bryce will either sell Edward or break him but I hope that the story won't end with the main character dying.
(Manish, 5th Grade, ELC Malaysia)

Chapter 18

I really like all the big words they use In the book

Chapter 19-20

I really wish Sarah Ruth did not die it was really sad but shocking when jangles/Edward saw pellagrina.

Alyssa
ELC
Malaysia

Chapters 19 and 20 (Lydia)

I think it is sad when Sarah Ruth dies and then Bryce goes to Memphis and trys to get money. I also hate it when the father takes Sarah Ruth. Do you like the father?

Lydia 5th grade (ELC Malaysia)

Chapter 18 (Lydia)

I think Bryce's dad is drunk and mean. I figured out that the he in chapter 17 was the dad. I love it when Sarah Ruth, Bryce, and Edward went outside at night.

Lydia 5th grade (ELC Malaysia)

Chapter 18

Chapter 18 is when Bryce's father comes and he smacks Bryce across the face. I think that he is drunk or he does not care that Sarah Ruth is dying.
Gabe (5th grade ELC Malaysia)

The doll reminded me of Pellegrina.  The doll told Edward that it was 100 years old.  Pellegrina was Aboline's great grandmother so she is probably around or older than 100. I thought that Pellegrina's spirit went in to that doll.  Do you think Pellegrina has something to do with the old doll?

I wonder if Edward will get bought?

I think it was sad that Edward's head got cracked open.

Chapter 21

I wonder if Edward will get purchased at the doll store

Chapter 17

     I think that Bryce is very kind to his sick sister Sarah Ruth for giving her Edward because someone broke her last doll. I think Sarah Ruth is nice but it is sad that she is sick. I also think Janngles is a cute and funny name for Edward. Do you like Sarah Ruth?

Lydia 5th grade (ELC Malaysia)

Chapter 17

Bryce is a boy and has a sister named Sarah Ruth she's sick and lost her China dog so Bryce stoll Edward and gave it to his sister and she calls him jangles

Alyssa
ELC
Malaysia

Chapter Seventeen

I think its's nice that Edward has found a new owner and the name Jangles is cute but he most probably will lose Sarah Ruth like all his past owners.
 (Manish, 5th grade ELC, Malaysia)

Chapter 16

chapter 16 is when a boy gets hired by the old woman and when he is done with work, he steals Edward and runs off

Ch 16

Bryce is a boy who works for an old lady she uses Edward as a scarecrow but the call him a rabbit but he does not care and when the lady is not looking Bryce take Edward and tells the lady I have to go and takes Edward with him

Alyssa
Kuala Lumpur
ELC

Chapter 16 (Lydia)

I think Bryce is a nice boy. I also think Bryce is rubbing is nose so much became it is runny. In the story a key vocabulary word is descended and it means to go down. What is a key vocabulary world you herd?

Lydia 5th grade (ELC Malaysia)

Do you think Bryce will do something about Edward, and why?

Chapter 15

 I think that in chapter 15 Edward has given up love because he keeps getting lost. I also feel very sad for Edward because he is put as a scarecrow and he dled not like it. I think that when the big crow comes and does not leave and Edward thinks it Pellagra because he wants to show he can love.

Lydia 5th grade (ELC Malaysia)

Chapter 15

Chapter 15 was when Edward gets found by that old lady. I feel sad for Edward because when we thinks about the warthog, he does not care if he gets turned into one. And all of his family have gone behind him.

Chapter 15

I feel sorry for Edward because he has lost so many loved ones that he has given up loving g completely he's even willing to become a warthog. I wonder if he will ever find an owner who loves him and who he loves.
(Manish,5th grade,ELC,Malaysia)

I love how they have big words in the story like hollowness and weariness


Alyssa
Kuala Lumpur
ELC

I didn't like when Edward's head was smashed on the counter top it was sad.

The changes from Edward, is from how everyone has been taking him after he kept on getting thrown away.

How has Edward changed from the rabbit he was at Abeline's house to the rabbit that he is now? What has caused these changes?

Chapter 14

I feel bad when the train stops and someone was crying

Chapter 14

Chapter 14 was when Edward gets lost AGAIN!!!! I feel sorry for him and bull and Lucy and I think bull got arrested
Gabe (5th grade ELC Malaysia)

Chapter 14

     I did not like when Edward was kicked out of the train cart into the sea. I feel sorry for Edward because nobody ever goes after him. Why do you think Edward recited the names of the children or loved ones the hoboes told him?

Lydia 5th grade (ELC Malaysia)

I hated when Edward was smashed on the side of the counter top.  I also didn't like when Shara Ruth died.

Chapter 13

     I think that in chapter 13 Bull was funny but also nice and caring when he makes Edward new clothes and tells Lucy to look away. What do you think about Bull?

Chapter 13

Chapter 12 was when bull makes Edward new clothes and he says to Lucy, "don't stare at his nakedness" and that was funny

Gabe (5th grade ELC Malaysia)